The Magazine of The Evangelical Lutheran Church in America


Northeastern Iowa Synod council backtracks

The ELCA Northeastern Iowa Synod council backtracked in January, rescinding two resolutions it adopted in November repudiating 2009 Churchwide Assembly decisions related to sexuality.

The decision to rescind was made "after extensive and open conversation," wrote Susan Armstrong, synod vice president, in a Feb. 1 letter to the synod.

Rescinded by a 10-3 vote with one abstention, a resolution on "bound conscience" had said ELCA policies barring congregations from calling noncelibate gay or lesbian ministers would "remain in effect" for the synod. The council had encouraged leaders to continue the ban until the synod could put the matter to a vote at its June assembly.

The second resolution was rescinded by a 9-4 vote, with one abstention. It dealt with the 2009 Churchwide Assembly's adoption of a human sexuality social statement and its vote to allow congregations — if they choose — to call a minister in a committed same-sex relationship.

Those decisions were "violations of the Confession of Faith, Chapter 2 of the ELCA Constitution," the resolution said, asking the ELCA Church Council to "repudiate" and work to overturn them.

Armstrong wrote that some thought the council had placed itself "as a higher authority than the local congregation" or the Churchwide Assembly. In some cases, she noted, the action was misinterpreted as a synod vote to leave the ELCA. "Nothing could be further from the truth," she wrote.


Phil Iversen

Phil Iversen

Posted at 9:54 pm (U.S. Eastern) 2/26/2010

The ELCA made a bold and positive move on the homosexual issue.  All churches must face this issue in the near future.  Do not be faint of heart and move backward now.  Phil Iveren



Posted at 11:58 am (U.S. Eastern) 2/27/2010

The key the Northeastern Iowa Synod has given to all of us is the model of problem solving with one another through the use of "Extensive and Open Conversation."   When we don't value one another sufficiently to take the time to listen to one another, then our relationships are transformed from caring and cherishing relationships to ones based upon a violation to the dignity of all.  I am speaking first hand because the leadership of the congregation of which I am a member refuses to engage in ANY dialog telling us "it is not open for discussion." I think this is a form of violence.    

Print subscribers and supporting Web members may comment.

Log in or Subscribe to comment.

text size:

this page: email | print

February issue


Embracing diversity